Of course an Axiom is not really a stable datum, however, if an Axiom is used as a basis for all layers of knowledge such as with Scientology, then with such uncertain basis the spiritual technology is incorrect and therefore doomed to bring forth failure.
Here are all the Scientology Axioms with their inconsistencies flunked.
Axiom 1 Life is basically a static. A life static has no mass, no motion, no wavelength, no location in space or in time. It has the ability to postulate and to perceive.
Flunk 1 because only death is static. There cannot be a life static, only a life dynamic, otherwise there is no life. Life has nothing to do with abilities. Many life forms do not postulate, yet they do live.
Axiom 2 The static is capable of considerations, postulates and opinions.
Flunk 2 because if a static has no mass and no wavelength etc as outlined in Axiom 1, then is has no capability whatsoever. Capability is inherent with existence.
Axiom 3 Space, energy, objects, form and time are the result of considerations made and/or agreed upon by the static and are perceived solely because the static considers that it can perceive them.
Flunk 3 because whether or not there are considerations or agreements, space, energy, objects, form and time exist anyway. We need no agreement or consideration of any kind as to have the Moon in existence.
Axiom 4 Space is a viewpoint of dimension.
Flunk 4 because space is not a viewpoint. Even without intelligent beings with their viewpoints, space still exists. Dimension is used as a measurement aid and is not a phenomenon as part of or in the universe.
Axiom 5 Energy consists of postulated particles in space.
Flunk 5 because particles do not have to be postulated.
Axiom 6 Objects consist of grouped particles.
Flunk 6 because there are no ungrouped particles, and even if there are, then they are still objects.
Axiom 7 Time is basically a postulate that space and particles will persist.
Flunk 7 because time is a universal heart beat to which all levels and densities of existence abide. It is not the cause of existence, only the facilitator, and therefore is not a postulate.
Axiom 8 The apparency of time is the change of position of particles in space.
Flunk 8 because whether or not particles change position, time is as it is, no matter what.
Axiom 9 Change is the primary manifestation of time.
Flunk 9 becasue time is not sometyhing that manifests itself. It is a facilitator of existence.
Axiom 10 The highest purpose in the universe is the creation of an effect.
Flunk 10 because there is no highest purpose in the universe other than to exist.
Axiom 11 The considerations resulting in conditions of existence are fourfold:
a. As-isness is the condition of immediate creation without persistence, and is the condition of existence which exists at the moment of creation and the moment of destruction, and is different from other considerations in that it does not contain survival. – b. Alter-isness is the consideration which introduces change, and therefore time and persistence, into an as-isness to obtain persistency. – c. Isness is an apparency of existence brought about by the continuous alteration of an as-iness. This is called, when agreed upon, reality. – d. Not-isness is the effort to handle isness by reducing its condition through the use of force. It is an apparency and cannot entirely vanquish an isness.
Flunk 11 because everything is reality and facilitated by time. There are various kinds of reality, whether agreed upon or not. Reality is an absolute, because there is not any unreality. Reality may manifest itself in any density of existence.
Axiom 12 The primary condition of any universe is that two spaces, energies or objects must not occupy the same space. When this condition is violated (a perfect duplicate) the apparency of any universe or any part thereof is nulled.
Flunk 12 because nulling of anything is not possible, only changing of manifestation and level of existence is. Nothing in the universe can be destroyed, only changed.
Axiom 13 The cycle of action of the physical universe is create, survive (which is persist), destroy.
Flunk 13 because destruction is not possible in the universe, only change of manifestation and level of existence.
Axiom 14 Survival is accomplished by alter-isness and not-isness, by which is gained the persistency known as time.
Flunk 14 because time is not something that is gained. Time is a facilitator of existence. Mentioning any variation on the theme isness is useless because the manifestation of survival may change in density of existence anyway, regardless of any for of isness.
Axiom 15 Creation is accomplished by the postulation of an as-isness.
Flunk 15 because if Axiom 11 says that as-isness does not contain survival, then that is directly opposite creation because creation has as purpose survival, otherwise it is destruction, which does not exist in the universe anyway. Axiom 15 is therefore invalidated by Axiom 11 and vice versa.
Axiom 16 Complete destruction is accomplished by the postulation of the as-isness of any existence and the parts thereof.
Flunk 16 because complete destruction is not possible in the universe, only change of manifestation and level of existence.
Axiom 17 The static, having postulated as-isness, then practices alter-isness, and so achieves the apparency of isness and so obtains reality.
Flunk 17 because first of all a static is something that does nothing i.e. therefore cannot postulate. Second, everything is reality, regardless of the form or manifestation, and that also applies to alter-isness.
Axiom 18 The static, in practicing not-isness, brings about the persistence of unwanted existences, and so brings about unreality, which includes forgetfulness, unconsciousness and other undesirable states.
Flunk 18 because unreality does not exist. Everything in and of the universe is reality. Unconsciousness is not an necessarily an undesirable state, for example when you undergo surgery.
Axiom 19 Bringing the static to view as-is any condition devaluates that condition.
Flunk 19 because first of all a static is something that does nothing i.e. therefore cannot view, and second because devaluation is not necessarily the effect of of as-is viewing as such action can also result into valuation.
Axiom 20 Bringing the static to create a perfect duplicate causes the vanishment of any existence or part thereof. A perfect duplicate is an additional creation of the object, its energy and space, in its own space, in its own time using its own energy. This violates the condition that two objects must not occupy the same space, and causes the vanishment of the object.
Flunk 20 because first of all a static is something that does nothing i.e. therefore cannot create, and a prefect duplicate cannot be because the location cannot be the same. There is no own time, because time is the universal clock that facilitates existence. There is no own pspace, because space is a facilitator of existence. The theory of anti-matter cancelling out matter is void because nothing can be totally destroyed, only altered.
Axiom 21 Understanding is composed of affinity, reality and communication.
Flunk 21 because it is useless to mention reality because everything is reality. Moreover, affinity is not necessary because understanding can also be pushed, such as with indoctrination.
Axiom 22 The practice of not-isness reduces understanding.
Flunk 22 because fantasy can even raise understanding. How else are things being invented.
Axiom 23 The static has the capability of total knowingness. Total knowingness would consist of total ARC.
Flunk 23 because first of all a static is something that does nothing i.e. therefore cannot know. Moreover, “total” has not been properly defined and is basically reserved for the gods. Besides, ARC has not been properly defined in this axiom, in particular the weight or proportions other than “total”.
Axiom 24 Total ARC would bring about the vanishment of all mechanical conditions of existence.
Flunk 24 because total ARC has not been properly defined, unless only at the discretion of gods. And even then, nothing would vanish.
Axiom 25 Affinity is a scale of attitudes which falls away from the coexistence of static, through the interpositions of distance and energy, to create identity, down to close proximity but mystery. By the practice of isness (beingness) and not-isness (refusal to be) individuation progresses from the knowingness of complete identification down through the introduction of more and more distance and less and less duplication, through lookingness, emotingness, effortingness, thinkingness, symbolizingness, eatingness, sexingness, and so through to not-knowingness (mystery). Until the point of mystery is reached, some communication is possible, but even at mystery an attempt to communicate continues. Here we have, in the case of an individual, a gradual falling away from the belief that one can assume a complete affinity down to the conviction that all is a complete mystery. Any individual is somewhere on this Know to Mystery Scale. The original Chart of Human Evaluation was the emotion section of this scale.
Flunk 25 because affinity is very basic simple attraction.
Axiom 26 Reality is the agreed-upon apparency of existence.
Flunk 26 because everything is reality, regardless whther there is agreement or not. Everything exists and everything is real.
Axiom 27 An actuality can exist for one individually, but when it is agreed with by others it can be said to be a reality. The anatomy of reality is contained in isness, which is composed of as-isness and alter-isness. An isness is an apparency, not an actuality. The actuality is as-isness altered so as to obtain a persistency. Unreality is the consequence and apparency of the practice of not-isness.
Flunk 27 because everything is reality, regardless whther there is agreement or not. Everything exists and everything is real.
Axiom 28 Communication is the consideration and action of impelling an impulse or particle from source-point across a distance to receipt-point, with the intention of bringing into being at the receipt-point a duplication and understanding of that which emanated from the source-point. The formula of communication is: cause, distance, effect, with intention, attention, and duplication with understanding. The component parts of communication are consideration, intention, attention, cause, source-point, distance, effect, receipt-point, duplication, understanding, the velocity of the impulse or particle, nothingness or somethingness. A noncommunication consists of barriers. Barriers consist of space, interpositions (such as walls and screens of fast-moving particles) and time. A communication, by definition, does not need to be two-way. When a communication is returned, the formula is repeated, with the receipt-point now becoming a source-point and the former source-point now becoming a receipt-point.
Flunk 28 because a noncommunication can also exist without barrier. It can be decided or agreed upon to not communicate. Moreover, nothingness does not exist, and even the as-isness thereof is somethingness.
Axiom 29 In order to cause an as-isness to persist, one must assign other authorship to the creation than his own. Otherwise, his view of it would cause its vanishment. Any space, energy, form, object, individual or physical universe condition can exist only when an alteration has occurred of the original as-isness so as to prevent a casual view from vanishing it. In other words, anything which is persisting must contain a “lie” so that the original consideration is not completely duplicated.
Flunk 29 because anyone can have a fantasy, yet staying exactly the way before that fantasy. Even Disney managed so. And nothing can vanish, only change in form, level of existence or in manifestation.
Axiom 30 The general rule of auditing is that anything which is unwanted and yet persists must be thoroughly viewed, at which time it will vanish. If only partially viewed, its intensity, at least, will decrease.
Flunk 30 because nothing can vanish, only change in form, level of existence or in manifestation. How or why else can it be remembered after auditing if it has vanished? And there is no reason why something should vanish if it has been created. Better try manage it in a different way.
Axiom 31 Goodness and badness, beautifulness and ugliness are alike considerations and have no other basis than opinion.
Flunk 31 because opinion is not something to be dismissed or nulled. It is pretty useless to have no opinion at all when it comes to any manifestation. Without opinion there would be no impulse to improvement of anything. Why else must everything in the Scn Org be upstat? The universe may be viewed across a spectrum ranging from bad to good. It is up to the creating force to determine what is bad and what is good. And then we cannot talk in terms of opinion.
Axiom 32 Anything which is not directly observed tends to persist.
Flunk 32 because a direct obervation does not do the opposite. If a star is observed by an astronomer, even with the naked eye, still then it does not stop persisting.
Axiom 33 Any as-isness which is altered by not-isness (by force) tends to persist.
Flunk 33 because whatever form or manifestation, everything persists anyway regardless. Furthermore, this axiom is useless.
Axiom 34 Any isness, when altered by force, tends to persist.
Flunk 34 because whatever there is i whatever manifestation is there anyhow. Furthermore, this axiom is useless.
Axiom 35 The ultimate truth is a static. A static has no mass, meaning, mobility, no wavelength, no time no location in space, no space. This has the technical name of “basic truth.”
Flunk 35 because this is the ultimate lie! A static is nothing, and denies any existence in or of the universe.
Axiom 36 A lie is a second postulate, statement or condition designed to mask a primary postulate which is permitted to remain. EXAMPLES: Neither truth nor a lie is a motion or alteration of a particle from one position to another. A lie is a statement that a particle having moved did not move, or a statement that a particle, not having moved, did move. The basic lie is that a consideration which was made was not made or that it was different.
Flunk 36 because it is all relative. A lie for one is a truth for another. It all depends on the point of view.
Axiom 37 When a primary consideration is altered but still exists, persistence is achieved for the altering consideration. All persistence depends on the basic truth, but the persistence is of the altering consideration, for the basic truth has neither persistence nor impersistence.
Flunk 37 because there is no basic truth other than that everything is true except nothing.
Axiom 38 1. Stupidity is the unknownness of consideration. – 2. Mechanical definition: Stupidity is the unknownness of time, place, form and event. – 1. Truth is the exact consideration. – 2. Truth is the exact time, place, form and event. Thus we see that failure to discover truth brings about stupidity. Thus we see that the discovery of truth would bring about an as-isness by actual experiment. Thus we see that an ultimate truth would have no time, place, form or event. Thus, then, we perceive that we can achieve a persistence only when we mask a truth. Lying is an alteration of time, place, event or form. Lying becomes alter-isness, becomes stupidity. (The blackness of cases is an accumulation of the case’s own or another’s lies.) Anything which persists must avoid as-isness. Thus, anything, to persist, must contain a lie.
Flunk 38 because it is the other way around, i.e. the consideration of unknownness. Besides, an alter-isness may be very wise or creative, and is therefore not necessarily stupidity. Not everyone wants to know the truth. This axiom contradicts many auditing processes that contain “imagine that”.
Axiom 39 Life poses problems for its own solution.
Flunk 39 because it all depends on the point of view. For the universe, anything and everything is life, and problems or solutions have no meaning. All is as is.
Axiom 40 Any problem, to be a problem, must contain a lie. If it were truth, it would unmock. An “unsolvable problem” would have the greatest persistence. It would also contain the greatest number of altered facts. To make a problem, one must introduce alter-isness.
Flunk 40 because if truth were not problemetic, then why is there so much law enforcement against emanating truth?
Axiom 41 That into which alter-isness is introduced becomes a problem.
Flunk 41 because alter-isness could very well be the solution of a isness problem. That’s why auditing uses imaginary comparatives in certain processes like Objectives and in OT levels.
Axiom 42 Matter, energy, space and time persists because it is a problem. It is a problem because it contains alter-isness.
Flunk 42 because even if it were a problem, then so what? Problem depends on point of view. What is a problem for one is okay for another.
Axiom 43 Time is the primary source of untruth. Time states the untruth of consecutive considerations.
Flunk 43 because first of all, time is not a source. Time does not state untruth because time is the universal clock inherent in the universe itself. As as the universe is true, then time is related with truth.
Axiom 44 Theta, the static, has no location in matter, energy, space or time, but is capable of consideration.
Flunk because in earlier axioms the alleged defintion of static has been flunked on multiple occasions.
Axiom 45 Theta can consider itself to be placed, at which moment it becomes placed, and to that degree a problem.
Flunk because there is no point in perceiving that as a problem, i.e. using Scientology’s definition of force vs counter-force. If it were a problem, then that would contradict placement.
Axiom 46 Theta can become a problem by its considerations, but then becomes mest. Mest is that form of theta which is a problem.
Flunk because materialization is not necessarily the result of either problems or considerations.
Axiom 47 Theta can resolve problems.
Flunk 47 because theta may need interfaces to resolve problems, simple because problems may manifest themselves in any density of existence other than theta.
Axiom 48 Life is a game wherein theta as the static solves the problems of theta as mest.
Flunk 48 because the definintion of static has already been flunked on multiple occasions.
Axiom 49 To solve any problem it is only necessary to become theta, the solver, rather than theta, the problem.
Flunk 49 because even if that would suggest that a thought would be sufficient to solve problems. Problems cannot be solved just by that. There are countless examples to come up with in the world of manifestations of higher densities.
Axiom 50 Theta as mest must contain considerations which are lies.
Flunk 50 because theta is mest, albeit in a lower density of manifestation, but therefore not necessarily a lie, otherwise it would not exist. So this axiom is a contradiction.
Axiom 51 Postulates and live communication not being mest and being senior to mest can accomplish change in mest without bringing about a persistence of mest. Thus auditing can occur.
Flunk 51 because everything is mest. Scientology does not use the basics related with manifestations of density of existence.
Axiom 52 Mest persists and solidifies to the degree that it is not granted life.
Flunk 52 because Scientology does not use the basics related with manifestations of density of existence.
Axiom 53 A stable datum is necessary to the alignment of data.
Flunk 52 because that contradicts the Scientology assumption that there is no absolute. Besides, alignment of data can be as relative as the data and its meta data
Axiom 54 A tolerance of confusion and an agreed-upon stable datum on which to align the data in a confusion are at once necessary for a sane reaction on the eight dynamics.
Flunk 54 because the definition of eight dynamics is wrong, as stated before. Moreover, a tolerance of confusion is exactly not necessary for a sane reaction. It is the tolerance of confusion that is insane, otherwise wrong would be right by default, which is the greatest nonsense.
Axiom 55 The cycle of action is a consideration. Create, survive, destroy, the cycle of action accepted by the genetic entity, is only a consideration which can be changed by the thetan making a new consideration or different action cycles.
Flunk 55 because a cycle is not just a consideration. A cycle of action is that what occurs, and simple as that. If an asteroid hits planet Earth, then that cycle of action takes place with or without consideration.
Axiom 56 Theta brings order to chaos.
Flunk 56 because mankind has proven to bring chaos in order, as mankind fucks up planet Earth and beyond continuously.
COROLLARY: Chaos brings disorder to theta.
Flunk 56 because chaos is the prime trigger for new inventions, solutions, and ordering such as exact science, i.e. anti-chaos.
Axiom 57 Order manifests when communication, control and havingness are available to theta.
Flunk 57 because disorder manifests with these elements. For example when there is a war, led by communication, control and havingness, there is little order and a lot of chaos.
0. The coming of the prophet 1. Love 2. Marriage 3. Children 4. Giving 5. Eating and Drinking 6. Work 7. Joy and Sorrow 8. Houses 9. Pets 10. Clothes 11. Buying and Selling 12. Crime and Punishment 13. Laws 14. Freedom 15. Reason and Passion 16. Pain 17. Self-Knowledge 18. Teaching 19. Friendship 20. Talking 21. Time and Space 22. Good and Evil 23. Prayer 24. Pleasure 25. Beauty 26. Religion 27. Death 28. Forms Of Existence 29. Real vs Virtual 30. The Farewell